Sao Paulo: ad space not available
by Michael Nielsen, (8 comments)
It doesn’t look like this has been given much attention on many design blogs, but it’s something I’ve been absolutely fascinated with over the past few weeks. Sao Paulo, one of the largest cities in the world, has banned outdoor advertising…and therefore design. There have been a couple great articles written on the subject, one of which is over at WorldChanging. And a friend recently sent me a video that takes a more in depth look at some of the events leading up to the ban, as well as some of the aftermath and how advertising companies and the businesses they work for are combating the ban.
One of the articles does mention 70% of people (São Paulo residents) approve. The other 30% must be the 20,000 people that lost their jobs as a result. I can’t help but love the thought of a city of that proportion without all the mindless clutter. Billboards have been so exhausted lately, deep down you have to question their relevance and effectiveness they have. I think I’ve shut them off in my head completely. But as far as a directional/informational tool…some sort of outdoor signage is almost essential for a businesses success. People have to be able to find you right?
It should be interesting to see how the creative problem solvers in those São Paulo shops will use their newfound fresh open palette of a city and dream up some truly unique and probably more effective advertising alternatives. One article stated that businesses, now with lack of outdoor signage, have resorted to painting their entire building their signature color. Ie: man giving directions “BP is the second bright green building on the left”. If all jump on the bandwagon, that will be one colorful, not to mention confusing city. And if they took down all the structures that housed the billboards, it could be one beautiful, visual-pollution-free city.
Here’s a tasty link full of visual goodness (If you come across any more, please post them). Here are a few other articles I found on the subject. Read up, it’s really intriguing. @designverb IHT
Comments (8)
Bennett said:
Pretty fascinating stuff. It seems like there could be a compromise. Stores should be able to have small signs with their logos on them. I’m not sure how you would specify the difference, but people need to be able to find things. Although this law will get rid of a lot of visual clutter, it is not exactly helpful to newcomers and tourists.
This also leaves a great deal of room for deception. If I sell gas there, all that I have to do is paint my store green and people will think that I am BP. While brands can do their own damage, they can also protect us from poor quality imitations.
Posted on August 28, 2007
michael said:
oh yea - this is super rad too. recycled billboard vinyl bags! http://www.vaho.ws
Posted on August 28, 2007
mootpoint said:
I think ugly people are visual-pollution. Let’s ban them too.
Posted on August 28, 2007
mootpoint said:
Just found this:
I think that I shall never see
A billboard lovely as a tree.
Perhaps, unless the billboards fall,
I’ll never see a tree at all.
~Ogden Nash, “Song of the Open Road,” 1933
Posted on August 28, 2007
Luiz Pryzant said:
Hello, we are São Paulo based designers, there was people who thinks the advertising visual polution is part of the city but we loved to see the real city under the old bilboards, in our opinion the comunication challenge now is to build real facades in spite of banners. Another info 30% of SP City population is 3 million people, we are the biggest population in all south hemisphere! we are the 3th populated city in the word (1st Tokio, 2nd Mexico City) and u can´t imagine the problems we got!
Posted on October 2, 2007
michael said:
thanks for the comment luiz, truly insightful. any talk of ending there being an end to the ban?…or does it seem that it will be in effect for a while to come? i’d love to see some sort of case study on how you’ve approached a recent project, given the new barriers you’ve had to face. thanks again to our man Luiz live in brazil with the latest breaking news!
Posted on October 2, 2007
Luiz Pryzant said:
The law is here to stay, heavy penaltys done the job, Rio de Janeiro and other cities are studiyng the same landscape regulations. The law limits shop signs to 1 square metter, mounted straight to the wall, and no outdoor billboards at all, advertising only in urban facilities like time/temperature totens, bus stops, etc. São Paulo was living an advertising battle since vinil cutting machines became popular 10 years ago, everyone starts to build backlights bigger and taller (uggliest) than his neighbor, we easily can live with this limits, is a small price to clean the old chaos, actually is a real bless for designers. At this time the old facades was gone but few new facades. Regards.
Posted on October 3, 2007
Timothy said:
I dont understand what everyones got against billboards. What if Im in a situation where Im driving across Missouri and I need a place to camp and buy toys? Then what?
http://www.timothykeen.com/bill.jpg
Thank GOD for the billboard.
Posted on October 3, 2007