It's OK to Copy, Right?
July 1, 2005

When I was in about fourth grade I loved to draw Ferraris and Lamborghinis that I found in car magazines and calendars. I had an arsenal of rulers, compasses, pencil sharpeners, erasers, and most importantly, several mechanical pencils. I would take apart and reassemble my drawing tools with the pride and precision reminiscent of that scene in the movies where the hero puts his gun together before a battle. I desperately wanted to create something as beautiful as those cars. As I drew more and more, my drawings began to look more and more like the photos I was drawing from. I developed shortcuts to measure and rescale the proportions from photo to drawing. I was proud of these drawings despite the fact that they were taken so blatantly from other people’s photographs. Click here to see a comparison of my drawing to the original.
As an adult looking back at that little boy I have a new perspective. I am filled with fear and concern because of the current climate of corporate greed where companies sue their customers. I think I am reasonably safe from a lawsuit by posting my plagiarized fourth grade drawing, but that’s not the point. The point isn’t about stealing music, either. I gave up Kazaa a long time ago. The nostalgia of my memories contrasts with the current environment that is very toxic to creativity. If I hadn’t drawn those cars for fear of being sued, or worse yet if I had been sued, I might not be a graphic designer today.
Fortunately I believe that the recent court ruling against file-sharing is a small loss in a much bigger war. The old regime of greed and lawyers will be defeated by the emerging open-source community. The battle will be won by and fought for young artists with deep arsenals of mechanical pencils and lead smeared wrists.








